BIB_ID
190596
Accession number
MA 22706.36
Creator
De Vere, Aubrey, 1814-1902.
Display Date
London, England, 1886? July 28.
Credit line
Purchased by Pierpont Morgan, 1908.
Description
1 item (4 pages) ; 15.5 x 10.2 cm
Notes
From the collection of William Angus Knight.
De Vere has not provided the year of writing but it is possible the year was 1886. De Vere discusses the inclusion of footnotes to a new edition of Wordsworth poems. De Vere also discussed footnotes in a letter to Knight dated December 15, 1886 (see MA 22706.23).
Written from The Athenæum Club on its stationery.
De Vere has not provided the year of writing but it is possible the year was 1886. De Vere discusses the inclusion of footnotes to a new edition of Wordsworth poems. De Vere also discussed footnotes in a letter to Knight dated December 15, 1886 (see MA 22706.23).
Written from The Athenæum Club on its stationery.
Provenance
Purchased by Pierpont Morgan from William Angus Knight, 1908.
Summary
Saying Knight's new edition of Wordsworth's works should keep to Wordsworth's first edition; saying "I should much prefer the first to the last : but I should think you will be able to find some tolerably early edition which is better than either; for some of his early poems certainly gained by the changes he made in comparatively early times; though most of the later changes were for the worse - some of them strangely for the worse. - If your edition were to be one selected out of the various readings of the different editions, a thing in the abstract desirable, I think it would be difficult to do this on the responsibility of any one person. You would need to put each altered passage to the vote of come of our best Poets, such as Tennyson, Browning, & Sir H. Taylor : & I doubt whether this would be practicable & whether, when done, it would be generally approved. - One thing I am confident about, viz. that if the new Edition is to be satisfactory to readers, as well as curious & of historical interest, the various versions must be compared, not at the foot of each page, but apart, either at the end of the work, or at the end of each vol. If the reader compares the different readings while himself reading the poems for the sake of the poetry, he will be so puzzled that the effect of the poetry will be all but lost. It certainly would be so with me at least. A tentative Faith in the poet is necessary while we read him for poetic enjoyment : & the critical spirit must work wholy apart at a later time."
Catalog link
Department